Sunday, August 12, 2007

Opinion Polls: An absolute waste!

India will celebrate its sixtieth Independence Day in about three days' time.

Such landmarks usually result in the media conducting another opinion poll. This time, the poll under the spotlight being NDTV's opinion poll that has been widely publicized and touted as a celebration of the achievements of the nation. To look at the whole results, one can just visit the NDTV website or that of the Hindu.

However, what I am trying to do here is to not list out the results of the poll, but to try and make some sense out of it. There are quite a few shocking entries in the poll, which would perhaps highlight the fickle nature of opinion polls as a whole.

The most interesting result to me is this: The Greatest Sportsperson from India?

1) Sachin Tendulkar 2) Vishy Anand 3) Milkha Singh 4) P T Usha 5) Lee-Hesh

Look at that again and you would probably realise that it is nothing but a product of media hype.

Was a legend named Dhyan Chand even mentioned during the poll? Or was he a part of Indian sport way back in the past that his achievements are now outdated?

Here is a man who single handedly put India on hockey's world map. For all of his records, Sachin is yet to be a part of a single World Cup victory and will probably never be. Well, he has given his best on many occasions but personally, I believe that Dravid has achieved a lot more in test cricket for India than Sachin.

Dhyan Chand, on the other hand, played an instrumental role in three Olympic Gold conquests. Even Adolf Hitler commented on his prowess and it is widely believed that the dictator actually specially requested to meet him.

Yeah, that was way back in the early twentieth century, but the very enormity of that achievement in those tumultous times merits great acknowledgment.

Now, another interesting result: Kajra Re selected as the fifth greatest Indian Song.

Can you even imagine how ridiculous that is? It merits no further comment.

The rest of the poll does not have results as shocking as that, but are still quite questionable. That is where I would like to ask:

Do such "greatest" opinion polls serve any purpose at all? Aren't they such a waste of media space? What's worse: TV shows host programmes that last one full hour on these issues, debating useless things in a completely nonsensical manner.

Well, it isn't just any other occasion. It's the sixtieth independence day, they say.
Then, on such an occasion, what should the nation look at? Its past "achievements" or the way forward?

Now That's something I would love to see the news channels debate!

Saturday, July 28, 2007

Is entertainment today just pure mediocrity?

I was going through a list of the movies released recently in Hollywood and to my surprise found that the only ones I could find were remakes or "milk-the franchise" types or those adhering to standard formula. Nothing new. Nothing original. Nothing interesting enough to make one like to watch a movie. But wait, what am I talking about?

The recent box office records show beyond any question that movies released recently (let's say the last two years) have set records especially in their openng weekend collections (POTC 2, Spidey 3, POTC 3, Shrek 3, HP 5.... the list goes on to reveal more such sequels an threequels and 'anything'-quels)

So should I correct my opinion now regarding the quality of the movies released in recent times? Or is it just that we have just got used to all the mediocrity that surrounds us?

Mediocrity is a funny thing really. One minute you hate it. Then, you get used to it. Soon, you even stop bothering about it. It is similar to the Shawshank prison so wonderfully depicted in the landmark movie "The Shawshank Redemption". The dialogue from Morgan Freeman, "The funny thing about prison is that it makes you 'institutionalised'" perhaps applies here as well.

Believe me, when I mention mediocrity, I dont just point at Hollywood. It applies to a whole lot of other areas as well. The media, Indian movies, music, writing, books, newspapers, journalism, politics, sports performances... you name it. The "mediocrity" virus is sure to have infected the field.

Let's take the media. I don't need to write anything new there. A whole lot of people have mourned the death of quality journalism and yes, I believe they are perfectly correct. Just a look at the various Indian news channel will do. A list of their various atrocities, in the last one month alone, probably deserves a whole new blog!

As for Indian movies, the leser said, the better! Sivaji, they said, will come, make people see it and conquer the box office. Well, it did. But, was it really worth all the hype and hoopla it got from the media? For heaven's sake, the film had an amazingly thin and preposterous storyline. With such a huge budget, surely the audience deserved better than just pure "style" and grandeur?

All of this probably applies to the world of fiction as well! As for newspapers, tabloids clearly sell faster than the hottest of cakes. Many people have even started liking trivial articles and ridiculous gossip about thelives of celebrities. Another effect of the "mediocrity virus".

As for sport, we do find excellence there, but no competition there.. at least not in cricket. As for tennis, the men's game is clearly a two-horse race (and Thank God for the "two" there) and the women's game clearly lacks depth and quality. As for the women players, one just cannot find the grace of a Graf or a Seles or a Sabatini among the Sharapovas and the Williamses of today's tennis world. As for other sports, the scenario is more or less the same with either total domination being prevalent or lack of depth or both!

Above all of this, the one thing that disturbs me most is this. The latest match-winning effort is the best ever innings by a batsman. The latest Oscar winner is probably the greatest movie of all time. The latest F1 sensation is perhaps on his way to being the greatest driver of all time. Such headlines are endless.

This is probably the worst habit of today's media! Just the sheer absence of objectivity!

Ah.... Enough of moaning and lamenting in my first blog!!!
All of this clearly makes me sound like an "in the old times" sorta guy.... but well, the truth is, I ain't one, but just can't help but feel the absence of quality!!!